Decatur, Ala. | Thursday, May 23, 2013
Font Size: A A A A

Common Core debate has a disturbing side

A disturbing aspect of the debate over the Common Core Standards, a curriculum developed by state governments and implemented in 44 states, is that the state’s routine attacks on the federal government have spread. Alabama now seems to resent its association with the other states of the union.

The Alabama Legislature, with considerable support from the people, has been waging a legislative war against the federal government since at least 2010.

Many of the laws the Legislature has passed since then, and the showcase bills this session, violate the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution. Federal law trumps state law, a fact some Alabamians resent. Even knowing the passage of unconstitutional laws inevitably results in futile and expensive litigation, some Alabamians support state laws that purport to reject federal authority.

There are compelling arguments that federal power has exceeded the scope envisioned by the Founding Fathers, largely because of the Commerce Clause. Interstate commerce, an anomaly when the Constitutional Convention of 1787 took place, now is pervasive.

Like the state Legislature, Congress constantly tries to maximize its power. The Constitution, of course, provides mechanisms to scale back federal involvement in the states. Unilateral state action — the method Alabama has pursued with enthusiasm — is not one of those options.

The Common Core curriculum, adopted by the state’s elected Board of Education in 2010, is not a creature of the federal government. It originated with the National Governors Association and the Council of Chief State School Officers. It is a voluntary and state-led effort to implement the best standards developed in 50 state “laboratories.” It provides uniformity, so a student transferring from one state to another can expect consistency.

The primary argument legislators make in seeking to overrule the state Board of Education involves claims of federal overreach. Common Core, though, is not a federal program. Common Core would have been entirely appropriate even before the Supremacy Clause made its debut in 1787, because it involves voluntary cooperation among the states.

Some legislators seek to argue the merits of the course of study, but their arguments are inherently weak. An elected Board of Education, with input from superintendents, teachers and other experts, studied Common Core carefully before adopting it. Taxpayers already have paid for most of the transition costs.

As board member Mary Scott Hunter — a frequent critic of federal overreach — told legislators at a committee meeting Wednesday, “I don’t want to tell you how to do your job, and I don’t want you to tell me how to do mine.”

Many Alabamians have a philosophical problem with expansive federal power. The hostility toward Common Core, however, suggests the frustration with the federal government has expanded into resentment of our status as one of the United States of America.

We are Alabamians, but we also are Americans. Healthy disputes over federal authority need not undermine our national pride.

Not registered? Click here
E-mail this
Print this
Comments
3 comments on this item

The common core is definitely federal, and was created to give more authority to the federal government in its failed attempt to continue demolishing, I mean improving public education.

You see, DD? It doesn't matter how many times you print the facts about a topic, there are going to be those who will refuse to give up their cherished - and biased - notions. (See above post.)

Leave it to m above and the repuks that are in office now & there won't be any public education in the very near future. ALABAMA the state of HATE & OPPRESSION!!!!!!!!!!!!!

You must be logged in to post a comment. click here to log in.
Follow Us On Twitter 
Decatur Daily @DecaturDaily
High School Sports @DecaturPreps
Living @DecaturLiving
Seth Burkett @DD_SethBurkett
Bill Campbell @DD_BillCampbell
Deangelo McDaniel @DD_Deangelo
Eric Fleischauer @DD_Fleischauer
Bayne Hughes @DD_BayneHughes
Ben Montgomery @DD_BMontgomery
Meredith Qualls @DailyMeredith
Mary Sell @DD_MarySell
Ronnie Thomas @DD_RonnieThomas

Alerts The Way You Want Them
Sign up for our any or all of our alert services & receive breaking local news, daily updates, sports, weather & more in your inbox or mobile device.
Mobile Devices
View our site on your smartphone or tablet devices.
Text Alerts (Subscribers Only)
Breaking news, bible quotes, weather, sports, horoscopes, stocks & more sent to your mobile devices.
Email Newsletter
Receive breaking local news, daily updates, sports, weather & more. Enter your e-mail address below.




Most Read
Most Recent
Most Commented
Events Calendar
Thursday, May 23, 2013 see all events
  • Thu
  • 23
  • Fri
  • 24
  • Sat
  • 25
  • Sun
  • 26
  • Mon
  • 27
  • Tue
  • 28
  • Wed
  • 29
Madison City Farmers Market
Madison City Farmers Market Lot
12:00 AM - 1:00 PM
Pickwick Belle, sightseeing cruises
Pickwick Belle Riverboat
1:00 PM - 2:30 PM
Daikin Festival
Morgan County Fairgrounds
6:30 PM - 9:00 PM
Madison City Farmers Market
Madison City Farmers Market Lot
12:00 AM - 1:00 PM
Pickwick Belle, sightseeing cruises
Pickwick Belle Riverboat
2:00 PM - 3:30 PM
Madison City Farmers Market
Madison City Farmers Market Lot
12:00 AM - 1:00 PM
Madison City Farmers Market
Madison City Farmers Market Lot
12:00 AM - 1:00 PM
Madison City Farmers Market
Madison City Farmers Market Lot
12:00 AM - 1:00 PM
Morgan County Girls Basketball Camp
Priceville High School
8:30 AM - 12:30 PM
Madison City Farmers Market
Madison City Farmers Market Lot
12:00 AM - 1:00 PM
Morgan County Girls Basketball Camp
Priceville High School
8:30 AM - 12:30 PM
Madison City Farmers Market
Madison City Farmers Market Lot
12:00 AM - 1:00 PM
Poll
What grade would you give the Alabama Legislature as it prepares to finish the 2013 session on May 20?