MONTGOMERY — An Alabama state senator believes he has the solution to the state’s debate about who probate judges can and cannot issue marriage licenses to: Do away with the state-sanctioned license.

Senate Bill 377 from Sen. Greg Albritton, R-Range, would end the requirement that couples obtain marriage licenses from probate judges. Instead, marriages would be a legal contract, witnessed by a clergy member, attorney or notary public, and filed with the state through the probate office.

“My goal is to remove the state out of the lives of people,” Albritton said. “No. 2 is to prevent the state from getting involved in long-term lawsuits that do no good.”

In February, a federal judge overturned the state’s gay marriage ban. But marriages were halted in early March when the Alabama Supreme Court ordered probate judges to stop issuing the licenses.

Albritton said his bill isn’t pro same-sex marriage — he said many of his conservative colleagues have to look to the right to see him — but a result of the recent confusion.

“I’m a traditionalist … but that doesn’t absolve me of my responsibility, our responsibility, of finding ways to allow for people to live their lives in Alabama without being caught up in this,” Albritton said.

Some probate judges stopped issuing license to all couples for a period after the federal judge’s ruling.

“We needed to have something in a policy and in procedure that could give people the ability to get married legally and lawfully without threat of being caught in some web of lawsuits.”

Morgan County Probate Judge Greg Cain on Thursday said he wasn’t aware of the legislation.

Albritton said his bill doesn’t change the rules about the current requirements to get married, including age. And it doesn’t change the state’s ban on same-sex marriages. That may be overturned by the U.S. Supreme Court this summer.

State Rep. Patricia Todd, D-Birmingham, the state’s only openly gay lawmaker, said the bill is another effort to keep gay couples from legally wedding.

“Why else would they be doing it now?” she said. “But it hurts straight couples more than it hurts same-sex couples.

“I’m not opposed to it; I’m opposed to why (they’re) doing it.”

Similar legislation was approved last month by the Oklahoma House. The sponsor there, Republican Rep. Todd Russ, said his legislation was in response to gay marriage being ruled legal in that state and was a way to “sidestep government overreach.”

Todd said those fighting gay marriage are in a losing battle.

“We’re not going away. You can try to put up barriers, but you can’t push us back in the closet,” she said.

This week, a Senate subcommittee voted in favor of a bill that would allow probate judges and others to refuse to marry couples.

Critics said it could apply to anyone, including divorcees and interracial couples. The House already has approved the legislation.

Albritton said House Bill 56 will lead to legal challenges for the state. “We don’t need to do that.”

He filed his bill this week, but Albritton has been working to gather support for it for months.

Sen. Tim Melson, R-Florence, is for doing away with the state-issued license.

“We didn’t have them until the 1900s. Why do we need them now?” he said.

Albritton said that so far he has received more support from the left than the right, but his bill is conservative.

“How much more right-wing can you be than to get government out of your life, particularly your personal life,” he said. “And what’s more personal than marriage?”

Get Unlimited Access
$3 for 3 Months
Subscribe Now

After the initial selected subscription period your subscription rate will auto renew at $8.00 per month.

Mary Sell covers state government for The Decatur Daily. She can be reached at msell@decaturdaily.com. Follow on Twitter @DD_MarySell.

(2) comments

Pamela Blakely

I look like a "real" writer with the typos. Sorry.

Pamela Blakely

To the writer - shame on you for not adding a link. [smile]

The link to this bill is at

http://alisondb.legislature.state.al.us/ALISON/SearchableInstruments/2015RS/PrintFiles/SB377-int.pdf

An old saying is 'the devil is in the details' and the old saying applies here.

Alabama does needs to get out of the marriage business.

What do we get with a current marriage license? Any marital counseling? Financial counseling? Any health testing? Nothing. Why? It is designed to raise money.

This proposal requires the contract be filed in Probate Judge's office. It is helpful to record documents with the Probate Judge because it maintains a record, but there will of course be a fee.

Why do we sell marriage licenses? Notice I said sell. It is a means of taxing the people.

We already have common law marriage. Common law marriage is as valid as a license marriage. What does a common law marriage require? A present intent to be married; open co-habitation; capacity (mental, age ...) and holding yourself out to others as being married.

The only "problem" with common law marriage is it does not have any written documentation.

So do I agree with this proposal as currently written?

No. Why?

1. It requires that marriage contracts are "... executed in the office of the judge of probate ..." No other contract has to be executed in the office of the judge of probate.

2. This is more of a tax than the current system. Best I can tell, the current marriage tax is $25. I must admit that I have not paid this tax in quite a while.

How much will it cost to get married under this proposal? $25 pursuant to Section 12-19-90, an additional fee of $30 pursuant to Section 30-6-11, and an additional fee of $20 pursuant to Section 3 shall be paid to the judge of probate. Grant total $75.00 to record a single piece of paper.

Tripling the cost to get married? Do they think they are a utility company?

They are on the right track, but, as always NO NEW TAXES (and do not double my utility bill).

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.